Skip to main content

Tesla “couldn’t flip” the Model X in internal crash tests: a look at the Model X’s safety features

Tesla Model X rollover

Tesla is already calling the Model X “the safest SUV ever made”, but the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has yet to confirm its independent test ratings for the vehicle. Through its own internal testing of the vehicle, Tesla expects the Model X to become the first SUV to get 5-star rating in each of the safety categories.

The Model S surprised NHTSA 3 years ago when it first tested it and the car even broke the agency’s roof crushing machine during testing. Now, Tesla claimed they couldn’t even “flip” the Model X during testing, according to Dougherty analyst Andrea James who recently talked with the company.

As you can see on the featured image above, Tesla expects the Model X to not only get a 5-star rating for rollover injury risk, but also to have about half the probability of injury for a rollover accident than the next best SUV (rollover is often the main problem for SUVs in term of safety).

James recently test drove a Model X and was impressed by the SUV’s performance, but she said that she didn’t really care about how fast it can accelerate:

“I care most that the car is safe, because I’m going to put my flesh and blood kid inside.”

Here’s an excerpt from James’ note to clients this morning:

[tweet align=’center’]

Tesla not only expects to achieve a 5-star rating, but like it did with the Model S, Tesla expects to get a much better results based on probability of injury. NHTSA’s star rating is based on the probability of a serious injury in a high-speed accident. To get a 5-star rating, the vehicle needs to achieve a probability of injury of 10% or less, and Tesla expects the Model X to achieve around 6.5%:MODel X safety rating

Like the Model S, the X benefits from large crumple zones and a low-center of gravity.

Again based on Tesla’s expectations, the side pole intrusion is about half of the next best vehicles for both the S and X. You can see below a side by side aftermath of the Model X and next best SUV:

Now it is even safer to simply not get into an accident in the first place and the Model X can help with that, to a certain degree of course, since it is also equipped with always-on active safety features like emergency braking and side collision avoidance.model x active safety

It’s not clear when NHTSA plans on releasing official ratings for Tesla’s Model X, but James sees the upcoming confirmation of the SUV’s safety performance as a positive catalyst for the company.

We will keep an eye out to see how Tesla’s estimates compare to NHTSA’s official results.

James on her test drive:

FTC: We use income earning auto affiliate links. More.

Stay up to date with the latest content by subscribing to Electrek on Google News. You’re reading Electrek— experts who break news about Tesla, electric vehicles, and green energy, day after day. Be sure to check out our homepage for all the latest news, and follow Electrek on Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn to stay in the loop. Don’t know where to start? Check out our YouTube channel for the latest reviews.


  1. freedomev - 7 years ago

    EV’s are hard to beat when it comes to rollovers as with their low CG, more likely to break the rims off than roll. I drive a Harley Servicecar size EV trike pickup, a style that normally has to slow to near a stop to make a sharp turn yet I go zipping around as fast as a car can because of the correctly placed battery weight.

  2. Roger - 7 years ago

    Uhhh, Since when does NHTSA use a “roof crushing machine”? I believe the author is confused….

  3. JTE (@bitflung) - 7 years ago

    (last comment didn’t post?)

    sorry to reply to such an old thread, but i wanted to answer your question. see here:

    NHTSA has been evaluating roof-crush since the 1970’s.


Avatar for Fred Lambert Fred Lambert

Fred is the Editor in Chief and Main Writer at Electrek.

You can send tips on Twitter (DMs open) or via email:

Through, you can check out Fred’s portfolio and get monthly green stock investment ideas.