The island where electric bikes are illegal

Key Biscayne, a small barrier island off the coast of Miami, has become one of the only places in the United States where all electric bikes are completely banned, regardless of speed class, rider age, or motor power.

This week, the village council voted 4-3 to keep its sweeping e-bike ban in place, rejecting a proposed measure that would have repealed the restriction and allowed adults to ride electric bicycles on the island. The vote effectively makes permanent a controversial emergency ban enacted last year, which was originally framed as a temporary public safety measure following the death of a local cyclist.

Under the current rule, no electric bicycles of any kind are allowed anywhere in Key Biscayne, including Class 1 pedal-assist bikes that are legal on most public bike paths across Florida. The ban applies to both residents and visitors and has been enforced with warnings and fines.

Before the vote, there was major support for repealing or modifying the e-bike ban. Even the Key Biscayne Police Department had recommended loosening the ban, suggesting that the village adopt a more balanced policy allowing adults to ride responsibly while continuing to restrict use by minors. Despite that recommendation, the council chose to maintain the full prohibition.

The issue has deeply divided the affluent community, where many residents support the ban due to concerns about reckless youth riders and congestion on narrow paths. Others argue that the policy is overly broad and punishes responsible adults, tourists, and commuters who rely on e-bikes as a sustainable and accessible transportation option.

With no exemption even for low-speed pedal-assist bikes, Key Biscayne stands out as a rare enclave where electric bicycles remain entirely illegal – one of few in the US – highlighting the growing tensions around e-mobility in tight-knit communities grappling with safety, access, and change.

What do you think? Should e-bikes be completely banned in these exclusive communities, or should there be leeway for creating common-sense laws that promote transportation while ensuring the safety of all road users?

via: NBCMiami